Counting Muslims : A Club You can never Leave

- Outside Indonesia you hear things like "Indonesia is the largest Muslim nation" and the idea of joining with Malaysia to form a large Muslim Caliphate. So it was a surprise to arrive and find there are 40 million Christians and large areas of Sumatra are almost 100% Christian. And then I realised that the whole way of counting Muslims is open to question. One of the reasons for the name "Dark Ages" in Europe is that hundred years ago there was no freedom of religion; Authorities would twist the law to say that having a different religion was blasphemous and punishable by death. But actually today its that way in many countries. Usually people have their religion printed on their ID card. Incredibly although the Koran prescribes no punishment for changing religion Mohammed is supposed to have said "Whosoever changes his religion, Kill Him" Sahih Bukhari 9:84:57 Incredibly this is largely accepted as valid, so unlike people in the rest of the world you are not free to choose your religion. (But some scholars say Mohammed meant at that particular time not in general forever.)
Of course this is outrageous and against human rights laws and principles. So counting the number of Muslims in a country isn't a valid measurement. But the politicians are able to exploit this.

Wikipedia says -highly controversial cos
1 Quran itself is silent on the punishment for apostasy
2 The hadith (the body of quotes attributed to Muhammad) "Whosoever changes his religion, Kill Him" Sahih Bukhari 9:84:57 Is accepted as valid, but some scholars say he meant at that particular time not in general forever.
3. It contradicts the UN International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which says people have the right to choose religion.
4. Islam Online, a hugely popular Muslim website, contains a fatwa dated 21 March 2004 'IOL Shariah" Caliph should kill the apostate
5. This death sentence is carried out in 6 or so extreme countries, but not indonesia.

Economy is Screwed means opportunity

For foreigners Indonesia seems very poor it's run down, little new construction and also very cheap; cos the Rupiah is so low dollars buy a lot. cheap Many people in Indonesia moan about the hard times. There's little money coming in cos of the lack of tourists & at the same time imported products like cellphones are expensive.

But I could see tremendous opportunities. Surely having a low exchange rate that means if you can export a product or service for dollars, then you earn a large amount of Rupiah for it. Unfortunately with so many systems broken or corrupt I can see that your profits could get swallowed up.

Where has all the oil money gone anyway ?. It's striking the difference with malaysia which seems to be prospering from the high oil price- there's a lot of development. In Indonesia is the money being stolen by the politicains and military and used to by houses abroad ? actually now Indonesia is a net oil importer so that explains a lot. Its GDP is $4K pperson as opposed to $13K

Back to Sumatra Index